Thursday, 10 July 2014

Rory Stewart OBE MP comes to Kent

It was an honour tonight to welcome one of the rising stars of the 2010 parliamentary intake to Tonbridge & Malling; Rory Stewart OBE MP. Rory was guest of honour at the Leybourne & The Mallings Branch Cheese and Wine, held at Leybourne Castle.

Rory is incredibly charismatic and delivered a thoughtful speech about foreign affairs, the Act of Union and on the pessimism which he feared is limiting our vision and influence in the post-Soviet settlement. It was totally free from hubris; not the standard speech delivered at Tory events, but Rory is far from a standard politician.

Tom Tugendhat and Rory are old friends, and he came at Tom's personal invitation. I suspect before long Tom will be flying to Cumbria to repay the favour. We were very fortunate to have such an outstanding guest.

Here is a photo of Tom and Rory (poor quality - sorry, lighting in these 900 year old castles isn't ideal for mobile phone photography!)


And, as always, a vote of thanks to the committee - without whose hard work and dedication nothing would be possible.


Twelve years ago when Steve and I first came to Kent, I relaunched the Leybourne & The Mallings branch and for two years was its chairman; so I have a soft spot and fond memories of this committee. Of the members who worked with me 12 years ago, seven are still active and present above: Richard Brown, Gill Levine, Edward and Thirza Pugh, Gill McDermott and Brian and Joy Luker.

An amusing aside: Jon Botten led the canvassing team in Staplehurst tonight, but gave me a well-thumbed copy of Rory's book "The Places in Between" for Rory to sign. I placed the book down on the desk Rory was using to help carry a box of wine, but when I returned the book had gone. Apparently, someone had bought it! Fearing the wrath of Jon, I had to go around the 70 guests asking if they had it, finally tracking it down to a man who I didn't know and who also happened to be deaf. I then had to explain very loudly that the book he had just bought was not for sale and that I really needed it back as it belonged to a friend. I managed to convince him, handed back the £10 he paid for it (which I didn't have the heart to reclaim from the branch) and rescued my credibility with Jon; who I can now look in the eye when I return to the office next week!

Look what arrived in the post today!

Lovely to see former Members of Parliament continuing to support their local Associations. (Though this one is exceptional in many ways!)



Wednesday, 9 July 2014

A few further thoughts on LG Selections

On Sunday I attended a branch meeting in Rochester and Strood constituency (where I live and pay my subscription) to select two local government candidates for next year's Medway Council elections in the Rochester West ward.

Last evening I attended the second (of probably six or seven meetings) which will culminate in the selection of Tonbridge & Malling's 2015 local government candidates. Like Medway, Tonbridge & Malling is "all out" so we need to identify 40 candidates. Not forgetting 7 more in those parts of Sevenoaks which fall within the T&M constituency boundary.

Chatham & Aylesford selections are already underway. 30 candidates required, split between Medway (12) and Tonbridge & Malling borough (18).  Today I will be commencing the process in Tunbridge Wells (out in thirds - 15 candidates needed).

I mention this because all the above Associations follow the CCHQ Mandatory Selection Rules precisely. These rules are fair, open and transparent. Over the last 5 years, as I have guided each Association through the new process, there have been concerns and complaints. People are reluctant to change, and clearly some councillors did not like the thought of being accountable to the Association for part of their performance. But now the system is in place I don't think anyone would wish to change it.

Concerns, questions and advice about LG selections probably generate more email and phone calls via my blog than any other issue. In the last week alone I have taken calls from 5 Conservative Group leaders and maybe 10 Associations seeking help. Almost always these are from people who have read about our open and accountable system in West Kent and wish to replicate it locally. I am always happy to help; though I refer specific issues or complaints to their local CCHQ party manager or similar.

For the record we follow three stages

Stage 1: Confirming the intentions of incumbent councillors, receiving their completed re-application form and interviewing them to ensure they are suitable to go back onto the "Approved List".

Stage 2: Interviewing new applicants who wish to stand for the first time.

Stage 3: Selections

In all the West Kent Associations mentioned above, the initial interviewing (stages 1 and 2) is done by a Local Government Committee appointed by the Executive Council. The committee consists of the Officers of the Association, Council Leader(s) and Whip(s) (or their representatives) and additional members elected by the Executive Council. Given the Council Leadership has its own representation, the local Associations insists that the additional elected members are not councillors.  This ensures the Local Government Committee is not a sub-committee of the Council Group.

Obviously if there is a vested interest, members must withdraw from the process to avoid conflict. This means incumbent councillors seeking re-election or anyone who is on the Approved List cannot participate in the reapproval of incumbent councillors. (Imagine the outcry - and the appeal - if a councillor was deselected and then found three of the people who voted against him were after his seat!).

Once incumbent councillors and new applicants have been approved, we move onto ward selections. Each contest is "open" and anyone on the "Approved List" may apply for any seat. In reality, they don't. People know where the vacancies are and were good councillors have local support. In all the years I have been managing this process I have only seen two or three "malicious" contests, and in each case the challenger was given short shrift. There have been many more open contests where two or more people have applied for a vacant seat, and on several occasions contests brought about by a group within the community / local branch feeling someone else would be a better candidate. My job is to ensure any such contest is conducted openly, transparently and within the rules.

As far as I can see, councillors have responsibilities to three groups:

1. Their electorate; who can remove them via the ballot box if they want someone else.

2. Their Council Group; they are after all in receipt of the whip and have a duty to the Conservative Group/leadership. If they fail to perform in the council environment they are accountable to the Leader or Whip for their actions

3. The Conservative Association; at the end of the day, they stand as the Conservative candidate and as such must contribute to the political goals of the Association, who select them, campaign for them and ultimately whose "brand" they use to get themselves elected.

Very recently a Group Leader complained very loudly that under the new rules, the Conservative Council Group had 'lost control' of the process. Apparently councillors were far better placed to decide these matters as they knew each other and could therefore make better judgements. Quite apart from the fact that council performance is only one of many performance criteria, the concept of democracy, accountability and the rights of the membership seem to have passed this leader by.

I did suggest that I would write to CCHQ putting forward this view if, and only if, he would agree to the Group Leader and he Cabinet being elected by the local Conservative Party membership without consulting the councillors. He wasn't keen on that idea either, strangely enough!

There is a simple balance.

  • The Conservative Association / membership has the right to select its candidates. 
  • The people have a right to elect their councillor. 
  • The leader of the Conservative Group (elected by the councillors) has a right to select his/her team and develop/ implement policy.

Tuesday, 8 July 2014

Thank you leaflets, Baroness Trumpington and LG Selections !

Busy day at the office!

Finished printing the thank you leaflets for all our Tunbridge Wells candidates. It's a small touch, and the A5 leaflets only costs £25 per ward, but its a worthwhile thing to do.

 


We also sent out 1,500 invitations to the Coming Up Trumps event, with Baroness Trumpington. My thanks to Gill Levine, Sue Nuttall, Vivian Branson and Janet Sergison for their help and support with packing.



This evening, we commenced the Tonbridge & Malling Local Government Committee interviews for 2015.

Staplehurst By Election - leaflet number two

For the anoraks and nerds, here is our second ward-wide leaflet for the Staplehurst by-election.


    

Just in case the embedding code doesn't work, here is a LINK


Monday, 7 July 2014

Craig Mackinlay is a decent man and will make a great MP

Three battle-scarred friends with our respective long-suffering partners regrouped for a meal last night to celebrate Craig Mackinlay's selection as Parliamentary Candidate in South Thanet.


The three of us are all, in our own way, consumed by politics. Our partners really have no interest whatsoever. I think it's fair to say that the picture tells its own story. If you want to stay young, smooth skinned and beautiful, get a proper job that does not involve midnight meetings and tramping the streets in search of votes.


I really am pleased for Craig and wish him every success. I tend to take a sanguine view of elections; I fight each and every one like fury, I often feel the outcome matters more to me than the candidates, but once they are over I close the book and move on. Win or lose, I know I have done my best and I always accept the outcome. The Kent Police & Crime Commissioner campaign is a case in point. It was a hard campaign and a bruising result - but Craig took the blow on the chin, dusted himself down, and came back fighting. Many lesser men would have allowed it to damage them or dent their confidence, but not Craig. He is a conviction politician who believes passionately in his position and is unafraid to fight his corner. He is a good man and willl make a great MP.

Sunday, 6 July 2014

LG Candidate Selections in Rochester & Strood.

I did something very unusual today: I was a rank and file activist!

Very sadly, on a rare weekend off I actually attended a Conservative Party meeting, but for once I was not putting out the chairs and ticking off names - I was sitting in the body of the meeting as a member. The meeting in question was a local government selection meeting for the branch where I live (and pay my subscription); Rochester West in the Rochester & Strood Association.

Like Tonbridge & Malling and Tunbridge Wells, Rochester & Strood do these things by the book. Every incumbent councillor must re-apply and is re-interviewed. If re-approved (and three incumbents were not) their names go onto the " approved list". Next, new applicants are interviewed, and if deemed suitable, their names also go onto the "approved list". Each ward then selects its candidates. If the local membership is sufficiently large (ie 2% of the previous Conservative vote) the branch members select their own candidate at a special general meeting. If the membership does not qualify, the Executive Council selects. Anyone on the "approved list" may apply for any seat. Simple. Transparent. Democratic.  

Today's selection originally saw EIGHT candidates competing for two seats. (Let me repeat that - EIGHT candidates competing for two seats). For those who don't like the new selection rules or open contests, ask yourself when any branch in your Association had eight applicants for two seats.  However, from those eight, by the time we had reached today's selection meeting, two had been selected for other wards and two had withdrawn; leaving a contest between four (including one incumbent, the other incumbent having been removed from the "approved list" at an earlier stage).

The applicants drew lots and each had five minutes to speak and a further five minutes to answer questions. The thing which struck me was how seriously each applicants took the process and the effort they had all put into their presentations. The other remarkable factor was despite the meeting being 4pm on a Sunday (and at the same time as the Wimbledon final) 24 members of the branch turned up to participate and vote (that's over 50% of the branch membership).

At the end of the process, and after two ballots, the incumbent councillor and another councillor from a neighbouring ward who has chosen not to re-contest his seat but move closer to home,  were selected. I am pleased to report that all four candidates acquitted themselves well and each drew considerable support. It was also interesting (and gratifying) to see Mark Reckless MP at the meeting; but he was not at the top table as a "guest" but sitting quietly in the audience with the other members and participating in the process (he lives in the ward and was excercising his right as any other paid-up member - and why not?)

So congratulations to Kelly Tolhurst and Chris Irvine on their selection. But more importantly, congratulations to Rochester and Strood Constituency Conservative Association for running an open and democratic process and for allowing me, as a paid-up member, a real choice in who should be my local Conservative candidate.   Just as it should be done.

Officers from the Rochester and Strood Association
at the Rochester West Ward selection contest.






Friday, 4 July 2014

Coming Up Trumps; An Evening with Baroness Trumpington

I've dropped a few hints - but now it's official and confirmed! 


West Kent Conservatives are delighted to announce: 
Coming Up Trumps: An Evening with Baroness Trumpington.
Thursday 4 September 2014 at The Hazlitt Theatre, Maidstone. 


If anyone would like to attend, send me a message via this blog or phone the West Kent Campaign HQ on 01732 842794. 



How UKIP supporters vote when UKIP isn't an option.

There is a widely held view that UKIP supporters are disproportionately former Conservatives, particularly in the south.

Whilst this may have been true four years ago I don't believe this is not the case now, and in the Midlands and the North UKIP probably damage Labour.

The following table, however, is of interest. On 22 May we had a district election and a town council by-election in the same ward, with identical boundaries. UKIP contested the district seat but not the town council seat. Here is the result

So here we have 1,400 people voting, in the same place and at the same time, with and without a UKIP candidate to choose from. As you can see, the absence of the UKIP candidate results in Con +4% LD +5% and Lab +6%. 

Food for thought for those who think swinging to the hard right will 'bring home' the lost UKIP voters. 


Thursday, 3 July 2014

Free moving organs and lead in your pencil. A typical night out in Tonbridge.

Last year I was asked to be "Quiz Master" at Tonbridge Branch's Annual Quiz and Fish & Chip Supper.  I thought it went quite well, everyone seemed to enjoy it and were very complimentary about my hosting skills.  I was therefore pleased when the branch set the date for this year's event, and I let the branch Chairman (who just happens to be our Director of Paperclips, Jon Botten) know that I would be very happy to host the evening again.

There was a bit of an awkward silence and looking at his shoes, before he admitted that whilst his committee thought I was "very good" they had considered asking me again but had decided they wanted someone with a bit more "star quality".

"Oh, that's OK", I said, through gritted teeth. I knew that Tom Tugendhat or Dame Kelly Holmes would attract a far bigger crowd than the agent who irritates everyone by sending out grumpy emails demanding they all work harder. But inside, deep inside, it hurt!  I knew how an actor must feel to be turned down at audition for a fresher face.

A month went by and I saw no evidence of activity or a flyer promoting the event. "How's your quiz going?" I asked, genuinely interested. "Have you started selling tickets yet?"  "Oh Yes", said JB.  "I've been meaning to mention it to you. Tom Tugendhat's probably away and no-one else we asked wanted to do it, so we were wondering if you would mind stepping in again?"  Inside my head the words, "bugger off, you didn't want me originally so don't come running now you're stuck" formed. But by the time they reached my mouth they had changed to, "yes, OK then, if you're stuck."  Secretly I was quite pleased, though I wasn't going to let them see that!


With my lovely assistant and score keeper, Jenny Cooper

So last night was the big event. There were one or two surreal moments, like asking a room full of 70 year old Tories "in which American city did grunge originate?" followed by the "pot luck" round, which included a question on "netball teams" prompting the Association Chairman to start audibly reminiscing about the ladies' netball team who once practised outside his university window. Things then went from bad to worse when the very next question was about "lead in the pencil" followed by "which free moving organ of the body is attached by a muscle at just one end?"  The few of us in the hall with smutty minds enjoyed the moment immensely.

Anyway - well done to Jon Botten and his team for raising over £500.

And if you need a quiz master next year, I am sure I will be available!